1. How long will you stay in the home?
If this is your forever home, you want the longest-lasting option you can get in Arizona's climate. Replacing underlayment later means lifting every tile on the entire roof again, not just the rest of the roof around a leak. If you plan to sell in a few years, it's tempting to choose the cheapest option.
“Plenty of people tell me they're selling in ten years. A lot of them are still here at fifteen or twenty. That's why I like a long-life synthetic: it covers the ten-year plan that turns into fifteen or twenty.”
What it points to:
a longer horizon points toward a long-life synthetic, such as the double-layer 30 lb base + Titanium UDL50 system. Whatever you choose is installed to the manufacturer's specifications, and you receive the manufacturer warranty paperwork at the final walkthrough.